All Honor Roll students in Mr. Braiman's class after 2002 read To Kill a Mockingbird. All Honor Roll students in Mr. Braiman's class after 2006 read The Natural.
If a student read To Kill a Mockingbird but did not read The Natural, which one of the following MUST be TRUE?
(A) The student was in Mr. Braiman's class before 2007.
(B) The student was in Mr. Braiman's class after 2002 and before 2006.
(C) If the student was an Honor Roll student, then the student was in Mr. Braiman's class before 2007.
(D) If the student was an Honor Roll student, then the student was in Mr. Braiman's class before 2003.
(E) If the student was an Honor Roll student, then the student was in Mr. Braiman's class after 2002 and before 2007.
